
Home Insurance in Ontario: Coverage, Cost and How to Choose
Home insurance helps protect your house, belongings and finances when something goes wrong. Depending on your policy, it can help pay for repairs after a covered loss, replace damaged belongings, cover extra living costs and pay when you are legally responsible for someone else’s injury or property damage.
The important part is knowing what you are buying. Two home insurance quotes can have similar prices but different coverage, limits and exclusions.
This guide focuses on a house you own and live in. Tenant, condominium, rental-property and seasonal-home insurance have different coverage needs.
Key takeaways
- Home insurance is not generally required by law, but most mortgage lenders require it.
- Compare what a policy covers, not just its annual premium.
- Rebuilding cost is different from your home’s selling price and mortgage balance.
- Sewer backup and overland water protection may need to be added. Check the actual policy rather than assuming all water damage is covered.
- Keep your insurer informed about renovations, rental use, a home business and changes in occupancy.
- After a loss, report it promptly and confirm the requirements and deadlines that apply to your claim.
What does home insurance cover?
A homeowner policy generally brings several types of protection together. Each has its own conditions, and some have separate limits or deductibles.
| Part of the policy | What it generally protects | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Your house | The insured building against covered damage | Rebuilding limit, exclusions and settlement terms |
| Detached structures | Structures such as a garage or shed | Separate limits and restrictions on use |
| Personal belongings | Covered loss or damage to your possessions | Replacement terms and special limits for valuables |
| Personal liability | Covered claims that say you are legally responsible for injury or property damage | Liability limit, exclusions and insured activities |
| Additional living expenses | Eligible extra costs when an insured loss prevents you from living at home | Dollar limits, time limits and eligible expenses |
For example, after a covered fire, different parts of the policy may pay for repairs, damaged furniture and a temporary place to stay. That does not mean every expense is covered. What caused the loss and what the policy says still matter.
Your belongings and valuables
Your overall limit is not always the limit for each item. Jewellery, artwork and collections may have their own limits or restrictions. Ask whether valuable items need to be listed separately, and whether an appraisal is required.
Keep an inventory with photographs, receipts and descriptions. It gives you a clearer picture of what you own and helps document a claim.
Additional living expenses
If covered damage means you cannot live in your home, this protection can help with the eligible extra costs of housing and living somewhere else. Ask how your insurer works out the extra amount, which expenses qualify and how long the coverage lasts.
It does not automatically pay every household bill while repairs are underway.
How do home insurance policies differ?
Home insurance wording varies between insurers. A familiar product name is only a starting point. You still need to read what is covered and what is excluded.
Three common policy forms illustrate the difference:
| Policy form | Building protection | Belongings protection |
|---|---|---|
| Comprehensive | Broad protection, subject to exclusions | Broad protection, subject to exclusions |
| Broad | Broad protection, subject to exclusions | Protection against the causes of loss specifically listed |
| Basic or named perils | Protection against listed causes of loss | Protection against listed causes of loss |
A peril is a cause of loss, such as fire. Named-perils coverage lists the causes it covers. Broader coverage generally works the other way: it covers everything except the causes it lists as excluded. Conditions and limits apply either way.
Neither “comprehensive” nor “all risks” means everything is covered. You still need to check water exclusions, maintenance requirements and special item limits.
When comparing quotes, ask: What would this policy cover that the other one would not?
How much does home insurance cost in Ontario?
There is no single price that describes every Ontario home. Your premium depends on the property, its location, the coverage you choose and the insurer assessing it.
Published averages can help you understand the market, but first check what each figure measures. You cannot directly compare a quote for a house that costs $500,000 to rebuild with one for a house that costs $1 million to rebuild. A median quote, an average customer premium and an average of the cheapest quotes also measure different things.
For your own comparison, request quotes using the same property details, coverage limits, deductibles and water protection. Then ask the broker to explain any remaining differences.
Compare the total price
Look at the annual premium as well as the monthly payment. Check whether instalment fees or other payment costs apply.
A lower monthly payment does not necessarily mean the policy costs less over the year. It also tells you nothing about the deductible or the protection you would have after a loss.
What affects your home insurance premium?
Insurers look at both the property and the coverage you ask for. Details that can matter include:
- Location and the kinds of losses common in the area
- Building age, size and construction
- Estimated rebuilding cost
- Roof, heating, plumbing and electrical systems
- Distance from fire protection
- Claims history
- Who lives in the property and how it is used
- Coverage limits, deductibles and optional protection
Different insurers may rate the same home differently. That is why it helps to compare more than one option, especially after a big renewal increase or a change to the property.
Keep the property information accurate
Before renovating, renting out part of the house, starting a home business or changing who lives in the home or how it is used, speak with your broker or insurer.
These changes may affect whether you can be insured, your price or your coverage. Tell them before the change happens where possible, and keep written confirmation of any policy update.
Does home insurance cover water damage?
The first question is how the water entered the home. “My basement flooded” describes what happened, but not which coverage might pay.
| Source of the water | Coverage question to ask |
|---|---|
| Sudden escape from a pipe or appliance | Does the policy cover this escape of water, and what conditions apply? |
| Backup through a drain or sewer connection | Is sewer backup protection included? |
| Surface water entering from outside | Is overland water protection included? |
| Water entering through a roof or wall | Is this cause covered, excluded or handled by an endorsement (an add-on to the policy)? |
| Groundwater entering below ground | Does the policy provide any groundwater protection? |
Insurers may combine several protections in one package or offer them separately. Availability, limits and deductibles can differ by property and insurer.
Do not stop at “yes, you have water coverage.” Ask which types, how much protection each provides and what you would pay yourself.
What about frozen pipes?
Coverage can depend on the steps you take while the home is empty, such as keeping the heat on, having someone check the home or draining the plumbing. Before travelling in winter, ask your insurer what your policy requires.
Do not rely on another insurer’s rule about time away from home. Get the requirements for your home and keep a record of the answer.
Choosing a water limit
Consider what is downstairs: flooring, finished rooms, appliances and stored belongings. Ask how the limit applies to damaged property, cleanup and any related expenses.
If your basement is finished, do more than check that the endorsement appears on the quote.
What is not covered?
Home insurance is not a maintenance plan. Slow damage over time, wear and tear and maintenance problems left unfixed are commonly excluded.
Other losses may require additional protection or a different policy. Examples to discuss include earthquakes, some types of water damage, business activities and changes in occupancy.
Running a business from home
Tell your insurer about business equipment, inventory and customer visits. A personal policy may give limited protection for some business property, but do not assume it covers the business or claims made against it.
Renting out or leaving the home vacant
A home you live in, a rental property and a vacant house carry different risks. Ask what needs to change before you take in tenants or leave the property vacant.
Other kinds of homes
Tenant insurance protects renters’ interests. Condo insurance must work alongside the condominium corporation’s insurance. Rental homes and cottages also need coverage matched to their use.
None of these can stand in for a policy on a house you own and live in.
Do you need home insurance in Ontario?
The law does not generally require home insurance, but most mortgage lenders require you to keep it as a condition of the loan. Even without a mortgage, consider whether you could afford a major property loss or liability claim yourself.
What your lender needs
The lender will usually need to be named on the policy. Ask what insurance it requires, the date coverage must start and what proof of coverage it accepts.
If you are buying a home, arrange this before the deadline your lender provides. Give your broker the lender details so the insurance documents can be prepared correctly.
Do not confuse the mortgage balance with the amount needed to rebuild. Protecting the lender’s interest and properly insuring your home are related, but they are not the same thing.
How much coverage should you buy?
Start with the estimated cost to rebuild, then review belongings, detached structures, liability and additional living expenses separately.
| Amount | What it means |
|---|---|
| Market value | What a buyer might pay for the property, including its land |
| Mortgage balance | What you still owe your lender |
| Rebuilding cost | The estimated cost to reconstruct the home |
For illustration, a property might sell for $800,000, have a $350,000 mortgage and need $600,000 to rebuild. Those figures answer different questions. The mortgage balance does not tell you what it would cost to rebuild.
Ask your broker how the estimate was calculated and update the property information after significant renovations.
Replacement cost versus actual cash value
Actual cash value pays what the item is worth today, after wear and age (depreciation). Replacement-cost protection generally pays toward a comparable new item, as long as you meet the policy’s conditions.
For example, the depreciated value of an older computer may be much less than the cost of a comparable new one. Ask which of the two applies and what you must do to be paid replacement cost.
Guaranteed replacement cost may pay to rebuild even when the cost is higher than the dwelling limit on your policy, if its conditions are met. Check those conditions. “Guaranteed” does not mean there are none.
Check more than the building limit
Ask whether the contents limit fits your possessions, whether valuables need separate insurance and whether the liability limit suits your circumstances. Check for any rule that reduces a claim payment if the home is insured for too little.
How can you reduce your premium?
Start by comparing suitable policies, then look for savings that do not remove protection you need.
- Ask about combining home and auto insurance.
- Ask about claims-free, security and other discounts.
- Compare deductible options.
- Ask whether improvements to the property affect whether you qualify or what you pay.
- Review the policy at renewal and after any major change.
A higher deductible means you pay more of a covered loss yourself. Choose an amount you could really afford to pay, then compare the premium saving.
For bundling, add up the yearly cost of both policies together and compare it with buying them separately with similar protection. Our home and auto bundling guide explains the comparison.
Before switching partway through the term, ask about cancellation charges and confirm when the new coverage starts. A quoted saving is worth less if a cancellation charge cancels it out or you are left without coverage for a time.
Which home insurance company is best?
The better question is which insurer offers the right coverage for your property at a good price. There is no single answer for every homeowner.
Compare these items side by side:
- Policy form and covered causes of loss
- Rebuilding limit and how claims are paid (replacement cost or actual cash value)
- Contents and valuables protection
- Water coverage, limits and deductibles
- Liability and additional living expenses
- Exclusions and property-specific conditions
- Annual premium and payment terms
- Claims support
Buying through a broker
A broker compares options from the insurers the brokerage works with. That may not be every insurer in the market. Ask which companies were considered and why a particular policy was recommended.
PolicyScanner operates as a branch partner of a RIBO-registered brokerage. The insurer underwrites the policy and determines claim payments. Ask us about the available insurers, how the brokerage is compensated and any applicable fees before proceeding.
You can review the insurer relationships shown on our About page.
What should you do if you need to claim?
Put safety first. Do not enter an unsafe building or handle contaminated water or electrical hazards yourself.
Once it is safe:
- Report the loss promptly to your insurer and contact your broker for guidance.
- Photograph the damage and keep records of affected belongings.
- Take reasonable, safe steps to prevent further damage.
- Keep receipts for emergency work and temporary accommodation.
- Ask what documents, approvals and deadlines apply.
The insurer’s adjuster assesses the claim. Your broker can help you understand the process and policy wording, but cannot guarantee the insurer’s decision.
Documents and deadlines
You may need to provide an inventory, estimates, receipts and a formal proof of loss. Ask the adjuster to explain the requirements in writing.
Reporting a loss, sending in documents and starting a lawsuit are separate steps, and each can have its own deadline. Do not assume that a deadline you read online applies to your claim, or that an ongoing complaint pauses a legal deadline. Get legal advice quickly if a dispute could affect your rights.
If you disagree with the outcome
Ask for the decision and the relevant policy wording in writing. If the dispute is about what something is worth or how much damage there is, ask whether an appraisal process is available and right for your case.
You can also use the insurer’s complaint process and ask which independent ombudservice can review your case. FSRA says it does not step in to settle disputed or denied claims. A concern for the regulator and a disagreement about coverage are not the same thing.
Frequently asked questions
Are home insurance and homeowners insurance the same?
The two terms usually mean the same product. “Property insurance” is a wider term, so check whether a quote is for a house you live in, a condominium, a rental property or another type of property.
Can I cancel before renewal?
You can ask to cancel, but charges may apply. Ask how the charge is calculated, and set up your new coverage before the old policy ends.
Will the insurer check my credit?
Some insurers may ask for your consent to use credit information for home insurance. Ask what they will look at and how it affects the quote. Do not assume the rules are the same as Ontario auto insurance.
Can I insure a house with older wiring?
It depends on the insurer. Tell your broker about knob-and-tube or aluminum wiring and share any inspection or upgrade records. An insurer may ask for more information, set conditions or refuse to insure the property.
What should I arrange before closing?
Confirm what the lender requires, the date coverage must start and the proof it needs. Give accurate property details and review the rebuilding estimate. A quote does not mean you are already covered.
What if an insurer refuses my home?
Ask why it was declined and whether documents or improvements could change the decision. A broker may be able to try another insurer, but coverage is not guaranteed for every property.
What information do I need for a quote?
Have your address, building age, approximate size, construction details, roof and system updates, occupancy information and claims history ready. Your current policy shows the limits and deductibles you have now.
If you are ready to compare, start a home insurance quote. We can discuss the property details and coverage questions before you choose a policy.
Compare quotes from 15+ insurers
Sources and review
This guide provides general information, not a promise of coverage. Your policy wording, endorsements, limits and circumstances determine how insurance responds.
Primary references consulted for this rewrite:
- FSRA: Questions to ask about property insurance
- FSRA: Property insurance and the regulator’s role
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada: Home insurance
- Insurance Bureau of Canada: Types of home coverage
- Insurance Bureau of Canada: Buying home insurance
- TD Insurance: Water damage coverage
- Intact: Home replacement cost