
Tenant Insurance in Ontario: Coverage, Cost and What Renters Should Check
Tenant insurance protects a renter’s belongings and finances when something goes wrong. Depending on your policy, it can help replace your things after a covered loss, cover extra living costs if you cannot stay in your unit and pay when you are legally responsible for someone else’s injury or property damage. That last part is called liability coverage.
It does not insure the building. That is your landlord’s responsibility. Tenant insurance covers the part of a loss that would otherwise fall on you.
This guide is for people who rent their home in Ontario, whether that is a house, apartment, condo, basement unit or room. Tenant insurance and renters insurance are two names for the same thing.
Key takeaways
- Tenant insurance is not mandatory under Ontario law, but your lease can require liability insurance.
- Your landlord’s insurance generally covers the building, not your belongings.
- A policy generally has three parts: belongings, personal liability and additional living expenses.
- If you or a guest carelessly damage the unit or the building, you can be held responsible for the repair.
- Protection for sewer backup and for water coming in from outside may need to be added. Check the actual policy rather than assuming all water damage is covered.
- Compare what a policy covers as well as its monthly price.
What is tenant insurance?
Tenant insurance is a policy for people who rent the place they live in. You pay a premium, which is the price of the policy, and the insurer agrees to pay for the losses the policy covers, up to the limits you chose.
It works like a homeowner’s policy with the building taken out. You do not own the walls, the roof or the plumbing, so you do not insure them. You insure what belongs to you and what you could be held responsible for.
What your landlord’s insurance covers, and what it doesn’t
Your landlord’s policy protects the landlord. It is not written to protect you.
| What is at risk | Landlord’s policy | Your tenant policy |
|---|---|---|
| The building and its fixtures | Generally yes | No |
| Your furniture, clothing and electronics | Generally no | Yes, for covered losses |
| Your extra living costs if the unit cannot be lived in | Generally no | Yes, if the loss is covered |
| Injury or damage you are legally responsible for | It may pay the landlord, then look to you | Yes, for covered claims, up to your limit |
If your things were damaged because of something your landlord failed to fix, the landlord may be responsible. Otherwise the cost is yours.
The last row works the other way. In Ontario, a tenant is responsible for repairing damage to the unit or the building that the tenant, someone else living in the unit or a guest causes on purpose or through carelessness.
So if you carelessly start a fire that damages the building, your landlord’s insurer may pay for the repairs and then look to you for the cost.
What does tenant insurance cover?
A tenant policy generally brings three types of protection together. Each has its own conditions, and some have separate limits or deductibles. A deductible is the part of a covered loss you pay yourself.
| Part of the policy | What it generally protects | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Your belongings | Covered loss or damage to your possessions | Overall limit, lower limits on valuables and how claims are paid |
| Personal liability | Covered claims that say you are legally responsible for injury or property damage | Liability limit, exclusions and any minimum set in your lease |
| Additional living expenses | Eligible extra costs when a covered loss means you cannot live in your unit | Dollar limits, time limits and eligible expenses |
For example, after a covered fire, different parts of the policy may pay to replace your furniture and for a temporary place to stay. That does not mean every expense is covered. What caused the loss and what the policy says still matter.
Insurers also sell add-ons, called endorsements, for things a basic policy leaves out. Identity theft protection and certain kinds of water damage are common examples.
Your belongings
This part covers the things you own, such as furniture, clothing, electronics and kitchenware. You choose the limit, so it should reflect what it would cost to buy everything again.
Policies differ in which causes of loss they cover. An all-risks policy covers every cause except the ones it lists as excluded. A named-perils policy covers only the causes it lists, such as fire or theft. Neither name means everything is covered. Ask which kind you are being quoted.
Many policies also protect belongings while they are away from your unit, for example in a car or while you travel. Limits often apply, so ask what they are.
Personal liability
Liability coverage can pay when you are legally responsible for injuring someone or damaging their property, up to your limit. It can also pay for your legal defence if you are sued over something the policy covers.
For example, a visitor could be hurt in your unit and make a claim against you. Liability coverage does not pay for injuries to you or to the people in your household.
If you damage the unit or the building
If you accidentally damage your landlord’s property or a neighbour’s, you may have to pay for it.
For example, a pot left on the stove starts a fire that damages your kitchen and the unit next door. This is the kind of accident liability coverage can pay for.
Ask how the policy treats damage to the unit you rent, what limit applies and what is excluded. Damage caused on purpose is generally excluded.
Additional living expenses
If a covered loss means you cannot live in your unit, this protection can help with the eligible extra costs of living somewhere else, such as a hotel and meals.
It is meant for the amount above your normal costs. It does not automatically pay every bill while repairs are underway. Ask how your insurer works out the extra amount, which expenses qualify and how long the coverage lasts.
What is not covered?
Tenant insurance is for sudden, unexpected loss. It is not a maintenance plan. Commonly excluded:
- The building itself, which is your landlord’s to insure
- Wear and tear and damage that happens gradually
- Damage from insects, rodents and other pests
- Flooding and sewer backup, unless you added that protection
- Damage you cause on purpose, or loss connected to illegal activity
- The value of jewellery, bicycles, collections and other valuables above their special limits
Exclusions differ between insurers. Read the list in the policy you are offered rather than relying on a general one.
A roommate’s belongings
Do not assume your policy covers the person you live with. A roommate who is not on your policy is generally not covered, and neither are their things. The section on roommates below explains the options.
Bed bugs and pests
Infestations are commonly excluded. Ask whether that includes the cost of treatment and of replacing what was damaged.
If you have a pest problem, raise it with your landlord. Who is responsible for dealing with it is a tenancy question, not an insurance one.
Does tenant insurance cover water damage?
It depends on where the water came from. “My apartment flooded” describes what happened, but not which coverage might pay.
| Source of the water | Coverage question to ask |
|---|---|
| A pipe or appliance in your unit that suddenly leaks or bursts | Does the policy cover this escape of water, and what conditions apply? |
| Backup through a drain, toilet or sewer connection | Is sewer backup protection included? |
| Surface water entering from outside at ground level | Is overland water protection included? |
| Water from the unit above or through the roof | Is this cause covered for my belongings? |
| Water that escapes from your unit into someone else’s | Does my liability coverage respond if I am responsible? |
Many policies cover a sudden, accidental escape of water from plumbing or an appliance. Two other kinds of water protection may need to be added:
- Sewer backup is water coming up through a drain or toilet.
- Overland water is surface water coming in from outside, such as after heavy rain.
Availability, limits and deductibles can differ by insurer and by unit.
If you rent a basement or ground-floor unit, ask about both add-ons before you buy. Without overland water protection, a policy may not pay for your belongings or your extra living costs after that kind of flood.
Slow leaks are different. Damage from seepage that went on for weeks is commonly excluded, so report a leak to your landlord as soon as you notice it.
Is tenant insurance mandatory in Ontario?
Tenant insurance is not mandatory under Ontario law. Your lease can make it a requirement.
Can a landlord require it in the lease?
Yes. A landlord and tenant can agree in the lease that the tenant must have liability insurance. Ontario’s standard lease, which is required for most residential tenancies signed on or after April 30, 2018, deals with this in section 11. If your lease requires insurance and the landlord asks for proof of coverage, you must provide it.
The requirement is for liability insurance. Whether to insure your own belongings is up to you. You also choose the insurer, even if your landlord suggests one.
Check what you agreed to when you signed. Community Legal Education Ontario, which publishes legal information for the public, says that if a landlord tries to require tenant insurance after you have moved in, and you did not agree to it when you started renting, you do not have to get it. If you are unsure where you stand, get advice before you refuse.
What happens if you don’t have it?
If your lease requires liability insurance and you do not have it, you are not meeting a term of your lease. Your landlord can apply to the Landlord and Tenant Board to evict you. A notice from your landlord is not an eviction order. Only the Board can make one, and you have the right to a hearing.
If you receive a notice, do not ignore it. Getting coverage and sending proof may resolve the problem, but get legal advice quickly. A community legal clinic may be able to help.
If your lease says nothing about tenant insurance, you do not have to tell your landlord whether you have it or give them a copy.
Is it worth it if nobody requires it?
That depends on what you could afford to lose. Two questions help:
- Could you replace your belongings out of your own pocket after a fire or theft?
- Could you pay for repairs to the building, or for someone’s injury claim, if you were found responsible?
The second can be the larger risk. If you, someone you live with or a guest damage the unit or the building on purpose or through carelessness, the repair is your responsibility whether or not you have a policy.
How much does tenant insurance cost in Ontario?
Published prices for Ontario renters mostly sit between about $20 and $40 a month, and some are lower or higher. There is no official average.
Treat that range as a rough guide, because each figure is for a different renter and a different amount of coverage. You cannot directly compare a price for a one-bedroom apartment and $30,000 of belongings with one for a house shared by four people.
The only number that applies to you is a quote for your own unit, with the limits and deductible you would actually choose.
What affects your price
Insurers look at both the place you rent and the coverage you ask for. Details that can matter include:
- Where you live and the kinds of losses common in the area
- The type, age and construction of the building
- How much coverage you choose for your belongings
- Your liability limit and deductible
- Add-ons such as sewer backup or overland water protection
- Your claims history
Some insurers may also ask for your consent to use credit information. Ask what they will look at and how it affects the quote.
Different insurers may price the same renter differently. That is why it helps to compare more than one option.
Compare the total price
Look at the annual premium as well as the monthly payment. Check whether instalment fees or other payment costs apply.
A lower monthly payment does not necessarily mean the policy costs less over the year. It also tells you nothing about the deductible or the protection you would have after a loss.
How much coverage do you need?
A tenant insurance quote asks you to choose three numbers.
| Number | What it means | How to choose it |
|---|---|---|
| Belongings limit | The most the policy pays for your possessions | Add up what it would cost to buy everything again |
| Liability limit | The most it pays when you are legally responsible for injury or damage | Check your lease first, then think about the building you live in |
| Deductible | The part of a covered loss you pay yourself | Pick an amount you could afford on short notice |
Adding up your belongings
Go room by room and write down what it would cost to replace what you own at today’s prices. Include closets, the kitchen and anything in a storage locker. The total is often higher than people expect.
Keep an inventory with photographs, receipts and descriptions. It gives you a clearer picture of what you own and helps document a claim.
Replacement cost versus actual cash value
Actual cash value pays what the item is worth today, after wear and age (depreciation). Replacement-cost protection generally pays toward a comparable new item, as long as you meet the policy’s conditions.
For example, the depreciated value of a five-year-old laptop may be much less than the cost of a comparable new one. Ask which of the two applies and what you must do to be paid replacement cost.
Your overall limit is not always the limit for each item. Jewellery, bicycles, musical instruments and collections may have their own lower limits. Ask whether valuable items need to be listed separately.
Choosing a liability limit and deductible
Start with your lease. Some leases set a minimum liability limit. Limits of $1 million and $2 million are commonly offered, so ask what the difference in price is before settling on the lower one.
Think about the whole building as well as your unit. A fire or a leak in an apartment building can damage several units, and the repair bill has little to do with the rent you pay.
A higher deductible usually lowers the premium, but you pay more of a covered loss yourself. Say a covered loss comes to $5,500 and your deductible is $500. You pay $500 and the insurer pays $5,000. Choose an amount you could really afford to pay.
Roommates, couples and students
Most of this comes down to who the policy covers. Policies define that differently, so ask the insurer to name the people covered.
Sharing a policy with roommates
Roommates who are not related generally need to be named on a policy to be covered by it, or to have policies of their own. Some insurers will put roommates on one policy and some will not.
If you share one policy, you share its limits. A claim made by one of you can go on the insurance record of everyone named. Ask what happens to the policy when someone moves out.
Separate policies keep each person’s coverage and claims history their own.
Couples
Partners who live together can usually be covered under one policy. Confirm that both of you are covered, that the belongings limit reflects what you own together and what happens to the policy if one of you moves out.
Students living away from home
A parent’s home insurance may extend some coverage to a student who lives away at school. It often comes with limits and conditions, and it may not apply to a student renting off campus.
Ask the parents’ insurer before relying on it. Check, too, whether the student’s own lease requires liability insurance.
How can you pay less?
Start by comparing suitable policies, then look for savings that do not remove protection you need.
- Ask about combining tenant and car insurance.
- Ask about claims-free, security and group discounts.
- Compare deductible options.
- Check whether paying for the year at once avoids instalment fees.
- Review the policy at renewal and when you move.
For bundling, add up the yearly cost of both policies together and compare it with buying them separately with similar protection. A discount on one policy does not help if the other costs more. Our home and auto bundling guide explains the comparison, and it works the same way for a tenant policy.
If you receive Ontario Works or Ontario Disability Support Program benefits, ask your caseworker whether your shelter allowance can go toward tenant insurance.
Do not lower your liability limit or drop water protection you need only to bring the price down. A saving is worth less if it leaves you paying for the loss you were trying to insure.
How do you get tenant insurance?
You can buy from an insurer directly or through a broker. Many offer quotes online and by phone.
A quote does not mean you are already covered. You are covered once the insurer confirms the policy and the date it starts.
What you need for a quote
Have these ready:
- The address and the type of unit
- The building’s age, construction and heating, if you know them
- An estimate of what your belongings are worth
- Your insurance and claims history
- The date you need coverage to start
- Any insurance requirement in your lease, including a minimum liability limit
If you do not know something about the building, ask your landlord. Give accurate answers, because the policy is issued on the information you provide.
Proof of insurance for your landlord
If your lease requires insurance, your landlord may ask for proof. Ask your insurer or broker for a certificate or written confirmation of insurance.
Check that it shows your name, the rental address, the policy dates and the liability limit, and that these match your lease. Arrange it before your move-in date.
Most policies run for a year. Renew before the policy ends, and send updated proof if your lease asks for it.
Buying through a broker
A broker compares options from the insurers the brokerage works with. That may not be every insurer in the market. Ask which companies were considered and why a particular policy was recommended.
PolicyScanner operates as a branch partner of a RIBO-registered brokerage. The insurer underwrites the policy and determines claim payments. Ask us about the available insurers, how the brokerage is compensated and any applicable fees before proceeding.
You can review the insurer relationships shown on our About page.
Which tenant insurance company is best?
The better question is which insurer offers the right coverage for your situation at a good price. There is no single answer for every renter.
Compare these items side by side:
- What the belongings coverage includes and excludes
- How claims are paid (replacement cost or actual cash value)
- Special limits for valuables
- Water coverage and the add-ons available
- Liability limit
- Deductible
- Annual premium and payment terms
- Claims support
The lowest price is only the better deal if the policy would pay for the loss you are worried about.
What should you do if you need to claim?
Put safety first. Do not enter an unsafe unit or handle contaminated water or electrical hazards yourself.
Once it is safe:
- Tell your landlord or property manager right away. The building is theirs to repair.
- Report the loss promptly to your insurer and contact your broker for guidance.
- Photograph the damage and keep records of affected belongings.
- Take reasonable, safe steps to prevent further damage.
- Keep receipts for emergency costs and temporary accommodation.
- Ask what documents, approvals and deadlines apply.
If something was stolen, report it to the police and keep the report number.
If you may have caused the damage, tell your insurer early and ask how to respond before you agree to pay for anything.
The insurer’s adjuster assesses the claim. Your broker can help you understand the process and policy wording, but cannot guarantee the insurer’s decision.
If you disagree with the outcome
Ask for the decision and the relevant policy wording in writing. You can use the insurer’s complaint process and ask which independent ombudservice can review your case.
Reporting a loss, sending in documents and starting a lawsuit are separate steps, and each can have its own deadline. Get legal advice quickly if a dispute could affect your rights.
Frequently asked questions
Are tenant insurance and renters insurance the same?
Yes. Insurers use both names for the same product. “Contents insurance” usually means only the part that covers your belongings, so check whether a quote includes liability as well.
Can I get tenant insurance for a short or month-to-month tenancy?
Yes. A policy usually runs for a year whatever the length of your tenancy. You can ask to cancel when you move out, but a charge may apply. Ask how it is calculated before you buy.
Do I need tenant insurance if I rent a condo?
The condominium corporation insures the building, and the unit owner insures the unit and the owner’s own liability. Those policies generally do not cover your belongings or your liability as the tenant. Check whether your lease requires insurance.
What happens to my policy when I move?
Tell your insurer before you move. You can usually keep the policy, but the price may change with the new address. Make sure there is no gap in coverage between the two addresses.
Are belongings in a storage unit or a car covered?
Often, but with limits. Ask what limit applies to belongings kept away from your unit and to theft from a vehicle.
I work from home. Does that change anything?
Tell your insurer. A personal policy may give limited protection for some business equipment, but do not assume it covers the business or claims made against it.
Does having a pet affect my insurance?
It can. Insurers often ask about pets, and some set conditions. Tell your insurer about any animal in your home and ask how liability coverage applies if it injures someone.
If you are ready to compare, start a tenant insurance quote. We can go through the insurance requirement in your lease and your coverage questions before you choose a policy.
Compare quotes from 15+ insurers
Sources and review
This guide provides general information. It is not a promise of coverage and it is not legal advice. Your policy wording, endorsements, limits and circumstances determine how insurance responds. Your lease and Ontario’s tenancy law determine your obligations as a tenant.
Primary references consulted:
- Government of Ontario: Guide to Ontario’s standard lease
- Government of Ontario: Renting in Ontario: Your rights
- Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 (Ontario)
- Community Legal Education Ontario, Steps to Justice: Do I need tenant insurance?
- Insurance Bureau of Canada: Types of home coverage
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada: Home insurance
- Public Safety Canada: Be a flood ready renter